Tomato Soup Two Ways

Tomato Soup Two Ways

Jump to Recipe

Two warming tomato soups built on real bone broth and good fat: a rustic tomato-vegetable pot with your choice of protein, and a silky roasted tomato soup topped with a soft-poached egg. Both are best when summer tomatoes are ripe and sweet.

Yield: Serves 4–6 (Way 1) or 4 (Way 2) · Active: 20 min each · Total: 45 min (Way 1) or 1 hr (Way 2) · Season: Best in North America in summer, when tomatoes and zucchini are at their peak · Best eaten: midday or early evening

Ingredients

Way 1 · Rustic Tomato-Vegetable Soup

For the soup base

  • 3 tbsp grass-fed butter or tallow
  • 2 leeks, white and pale green parts, halved, rinsed well, and sliced
  • 3 carrots, diced
  • 3 celery stalks, diced
  • 2 cloves garlic, minced
  • 2 medium zucchini, diced
  • 2 lb ripe tomatoes, chopped (or one 24-oz jar whole tomatoes in glass, with their juice)
  • 6 cups bone broth, chicken or beef (make your own with my Broths 101)
  • 1 tsp fresh thyme leaves (or ½ tsp dried)
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 1½ tsp sea salt (Baja Gold), plus more to taste
  • Freshly ground black pepper
  • To finish: a thread of single-estate extra virgin olive oil, plus fresh parsley or basil

Add a protein (pick one)

  • Shredded chicken: 2–3 cups cooked, shredded pasture-raised chicken (leftover roast chicken is perfect)
  • Meatballs: 1 lb ground turkey, beef, or bison, plus 1 pasture-raised egg, 2 cloves grated garlic, 2 tbsp chopped parsley, ½ tsp dried oregano, and ¾ tsp sea salt (Baja Gold)
  • Shrimp: 1 lb wild shrimp, peeled and deveined
  • Cod: 1 lb wild cod, cut into 1½-inch pieces

Way 2 · Roasted Tomato Soup with a Soft-Poached Egg

For the soup

  • 3 lb ripe tomatoes (Roma or a mix), halved (out of season, use two 24-oz jars whole tomatoes in glass, drained, saving the juice)
  • 1 head garlic, cloves separated and peeled
  • 2 shallots, peeled and quartered
  • 3 tbsp tallow, melted
  • 1½ tsp sea salt (Baja Gold), plus more to taste
  • ½ tsp freshly ground black pepper
  • 2 cups bone broth
  • ⅓ cup cream, raw if you have it (or full-fat coconut milk, or skip it; the roasted tomatoes are creamy on their own)
  • A few fresh basil or thyme leaves

To serve

  • 4 pasture-raised eggs, as fresh as possible
  • 1 tbsp apple cider vinegar, for poaching
  • A thread of extra virgin olive oil, flaky salt, cracked pepper, and torn basil

Method

Way 1 · Rustic Tomato-Vegetable Soup

  1. Sweat the vegetables. Melt the butter or tallow in a large heavy pot over medium-low heat. Add the leeks, carrots, celery, and a pinch of salt. Cook gently, stirring now and then, 8–10 minutes, until soft and sweet but not browned. Add the garlic and zucchini and cook 3 minutes more.
  2. Simmer. Add the tomatoes, broth, thyme, bay leaf, salt, and pepper. Bring to a boil, then lower the heat and simmer, partly covered, 25 minutes, until the vegetables are tender.
  3. Blend or leave it rustic. Remove the bay leaf. Leave the soup chunky, blend it smooth with an immersion blender, or blend half for a creamy-but-rustic texture. Taste and adjust the salt.
  4. Add your protein.
    • Shredded chicken: stir it in and simmer 5 minutes, until heated through.
    • Meatballs: mix the meatball ingredients gently and roll into 1-inch balls. Drop them into the simmering soup (after blending, if you’re blending) and cook 10–12 minutes, until cooked through: 160°F for beef or bison, 165°F for turkey.
    • Shrimp: add in the last 3–4 minutes, just until pink and opaque.
    • Cod: add in the last 5 minutes and simmer gently, without stirring, until it flakes (145°F).
  5. Serve. Ladle into bowls and finish with a thread of olive oil and fresh herbs.

Way 2 · Roasted Tomato Soup with a Soft-Poached Egg

  1. Roast. Heat the oven to 425°F. On a large sheet pan, toss the tomatoes, garlic, and shallots with the tallow, salt, and pepper. Spread them out, tomatoes cut-side up. Roast 35–45 minutes, until blistered, slumped, and browned at the edges.
  2. Blend. Scrape everything, juices included, into a pot or high-speed blender. Add the broth and blend until smooth. (With jarred tomatoes, add some of the saved juice for a looser soup.)
  3. Simmer gently. Warm the soup over medium-low heat 10 minutes so the flavors come together. Taste and adjust the salt.
  4. Add the cream off the heat. Take the pot off the heat, then stir in the cream and basil (cream can curdle if it boils with acidic tomatoes). Keep warm over the lowest heat. Raw cream isn’t raw once it’s heated, but it still adds lovely richness.
  5. Poach the eggs. Bring a wide pan of water to a bare simmer (small bubbles, no rolling boil) and add the vinegar. Crack each egg into a small cup. Stir the water gently, then slip the eggs in one at a time. Cook 3–4 minutes, until the whites are set and the yolks are still soft. Lift out with a slotted spoon and blot on a towel. (For pregnancy or young children, use pasteurized eggs or cook the yolks until set.)
  6. Serve. Ladle the soup into warm bowls and float an egg in the center of each. Finish with olive oil, flaky salt, pepper, and torn basil, and break the yolk into the soup as you eat.

Storage

  • Way 1 keeps 4–5 days in the fridge or 3 months frozen. With shrimp or cod, eat within 2 days and don’t freeze; seafood is best added fresh when you reheat.
  • Way 2 (without eggs) keeps 4–5 days in the fridge, or 3 months frozen if you freeze it before adding the cream. Poach the eggs fresh each time.

Variations

Season & Circadian Timing

Fresh tomatoes peak in North America from July through September, with zucchini right alongside them from June on, so this is the time to make these soups with garden tomatoes (out of season, jarred whole tomatoes in glass work well). The rustic soup makes a light lunch on its own or a satisfying early dinner with protein added, and the roasted version with its egg is cozy, warming comfort food for the early evening, before the sun goes down.

Nourishment Notes

  • Tomatoes — Their red pigment, lycopene, becomes easier to absorb when tomatoes are cooked with fat, so roasting them in tallow or simmering them in butter and broth is exactly right. They also bring vitamin C and potassium.
  • Bone broth — Brings gelatin and the amino acids glycine and proline, which support the gut lining, skin, and joints. Homemade broth that gels in the fridge is the real thing.
  • Leeks, garlic, and shallots — Prebiotic fibers that feed beneficial gut bacteria, plus the sulfur compounds behind their flavor.
  • Pasture-raised eggs — Complete protein, choline, and the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K2, with a soft yolk keeping them at their best.
  • Tallow, grass-fed butter, and cream — Traditional, heat-stable fats that help you absorb the carotenoids in the tomatoes and carrots.

Sourcing

  • Bone broth — homemade from pasture-raised bones (see my Broths 101), or organic and sold frozen (Bonafide Provisions)
  • Tallow — from pasture-raised animals, from a local farm or butcher
  • Grass-fed butter — organic, cultured butter from 100% grass-fed cows, or raw butter from a local dairy
  • Heavy cream — raw from a farmer you know and trust, or organic, grass-fed, low-temperature pasteurized cream (Kalona SuperNatural)
  • Eggs — organic and pasture-raised, from a local farm (Alexandre Family Farm)
  • Chicken, turkey, beef, or bison — pasture-raised or 100% grass-fed, from a local farm (White Oak Pastures)
  • Cod and shrimp — wild-caught, from a fishmonger you trust; check Seafood Watch for the best choices in your area
  • Jarred tomatoes (out of season) — organic whole tomatoes in glass, so there’s no can lining (Jovial or Bionaturae)
  • Shrimp — wild-caught U.S. Gulf, U.S. Atlantic, or Argentine red shrimp, with no added sodium tripolyphosphate
  • Salt — unrefined sea salt (Baja Gold); flaky sea salt for finishing (Maldon)
  • Fruits, vegetables, and herbs — organic, from a farmers’ market or local farm

With Love, Light, and Health,
Anna (aka Food Marshall)

FOOD MARSHALL APPROVED

Food Marshall Approved. Grain-free, seed-oil-free and refined-sugar-free, made from organic, local and seasonal ingredients. Our standards

Get new recipes and essays

Seasonal recipes and writing on light, circadian health, and living with nature.

Subscribe on Substack