A Food Marshall Thanksgiving: The Full Menu, Timeline, and Recipes
A grain-free, refined-sugar-free Thanksgiving built around a herb-roasted pasture-raised turkey, buttery fall sides, a grazing table of starters, and five desserts. Every recipe is linked below, along with a day-by-day plan so most of the work is done before the big day.
The Menu
To start
Set out a grazing table as guests arrive, then add one or two warm bites. You don’t need them all.
- Holiday Charcuterie Board — raw-milk cheeses, cured meats, fall fruit, and nuts, built right on a board. It needs no oven, so it’s the easiest way to keep everyone happy while the turkey roasts.
- Caramelized Fennel and Shallot Dip — a creamy, lemony dip to serve with crisp vegetables. Make it the day before.
- Goat Cheese Stuffed Bacon-Wrapped Dates with Rosemary Honey — sweet, salty, and gone in minutes. Stuff and wrap them the day before, then bake just before serving.
- Cranberry Brie Bites (Grain-Free) — buttery pastry cups with melting brie. Use a spoonful of the turkey’s cranberry sauce for the filling.
- Sausage-Stuffed Mushrooms with Smoked Gouda — meaty, cheesy, and easy to fill a day ahead.
- Butternut Squash Soup with Caramelized Pumpkin Seeds and Toasted Coconut — a silky roasted squash soup to serve in small cups while the turkey rests. It’s even better made a day ahead.
The centerpiece
- Herb-Roasted Pastured Turkey with Wild Mushroom and Shallot Gravy — a dry-brined, herb-butter-roasted bird with crisp skin, a deep mushroom gravy made from the pan drippings, and a spiced cranberry sauce with orange.
- For a smaller table, the Fall Harvest Centerpiece Salad with Roasted Herb Turkey Breast and Maple-Orange Cranberry Sauce gives you the whole feeling of the holiday with a turkey breast in place of the whole bird.
The sides
Choose four or five, or make them all for a big table.
- Cranberry Walnut Stuffing (Grain-Free) — all the savory, herby comfort of classic stuffing, with tart cranberries and toasted walnuts and no bread.
- Buttery Mashed Potatoes — Yukon Golds riced and whipped with raw butter and warm raw cream, from Silky Purées Three Ways. Spoon the mushroom gravy right over the top.
- Sweet Potato Gratin with Thyme and Gruyère — thin layers of sweet potato baked in raw cream under a golden Gruyère crust, from Gratins, Four Ways, and it reheats perfectly.
- Cheesy Hasselback Potato Gratin — potato slices stood on edge in garlicky cream with Gruyère and Parmigiano, baked until the tops are crisp and golden, from Gratins, Four Ways. Serve it in place of the mashed potatoes, or alongside them.
- Lemony Green Beans with Toasted Almonds — crisp-tender green beans tossed in garlic butter, lemon, and toasted almonds, from Lemon-Rosemary Chicken Thighs. They take 10 minutes on the stovetop, so they’re perfect when the oven is full.
- Brussels Sprouts with Bacon, Crispy Shallots, and Cider Vinaigrette — deeply caramelized sprouts with crispy bacon and shallots, from Roasted Brussels Sprouts Two Ways.
- Roasted Root Vegetables with Caper Gremolata — carrots, beets, parsnips, and onions roasted until sweet, under a bright lemon, caper, and parsley gremolata.
- Roasted Rainbow Carrots with Pumpkin Seed Pesto and Pomegranate — make the Colorful Carrots with Pepita Pesto and scatter a handful of pomegranate seeds over the top for a festive finish.
- Harvest Shredded Kale Salad with Nut Dukkah, Goat Cheese, Pear, and Pomegranate — a bright, crunchy salad that cuts through all the richness on the plate.
- The Epic Fall Harvest Salad — a showstopping salad of kale and shaved Brussels sprouts with maple-roasted delicata, golden beets, apple, pomegranate, aged cheddar, and spiced pecans. Make it instead of the kale salad, or serve both for a big crowd.
The desserts
- Classic Baked Pumpkin Pie (Grain-Free) — a silky spiced pumpkin custard in an almond or hazelnut crust, with maple whipped cream.
- Apple Crumb Pie — bake the Dutch crumb version from Grain-Free Heritage Apple Pie (Three Ways), with a buttery almond crumble over orchard apples.
- Anna’s Baked NY-Style Cheesecake with Raspberry Sauce — rich, tangy, maple-sweetened cheesecake with a bright raspberry sauce (coulis) spooned over each slice.
- Snickerdoodle Cookies — soft almond flour cookies rolled in date sugar and Ceylon cinnamon, easy for little hands and late-night nibbling.
- Cacao Brownies — pick either version from Grain-Free Brownies Two Ways, fudgy or cake-like, for the chocolate lovers at the table.
Make-Ahead Timeline
This plan assumes you’re eating in the midafternoon. If your turkey is frozen, move it to the fridge well before this week begins, allowing about 1 day of thawing for every 4–5 lb (4–5 days for a 20-lb bird).
3 days out
- Do the big shop and pick up your turkey, raw dairy, and produce.
- Make the stock for the gravy from the turkey neck and giblets (or use homemade broth from Broths 101 — A Foundation).
- Make the cranberry sauce. It keeps 2 weeks in the fridge and tastes better after a few days.
- Bake the snickerdoodles (or roll the dough into balls and freeze them, then bake on the day).
- Toast and mix the nut dukkah for the kale salad and store it airtight.
- Make the raspberry sauce for the cheesecake.
- Toast the spiced pecans for the harvest salad and store them airtight.
2 days out
- Dry-brine the turkey and set it on a rack in the fridge, uncovered, for 24–48 hours so the skin dries and crisps in the oven.
- Bake the cheesecake. It needs an overnight chill and keeps up to 5 days.
- Bake the brownies. They improve overnight.
- Roast the pumpkin for the pie, or open your cans of pumpkin purée and measure what you need.
The day before
- Bake the pumpkin pie and the apple crumb pie. Keep the pumpkin pie in the fridge and the apple pie loosely covered at room temperature.
- Bake the sweet potato gratin all the way through, cool it, cover, and refrigerate.
- Reduce the gravy stock and brown the mushrooms for the gravy.
- Make the butternut squash soup, if serving.
- Prep the stuffing (chop the onion, celery, and herbs, and toast the walnuts) so it only needs mixing and baking.
- Peel and cube the potatoes and keep them covered in cold water in the fridge.
- Make the pepita pesto for the carrots, and peel or scrub the carrots.
- Wash, dry, and shred the kale, make the dressing, and store both in the fridge.
- Bake the hasselback potato gratin all the way through, cool it, cover, and refrigerate, just like the sweet potato gratin.
- Make the fennel dip, and wash and cut the vegetables to go with it.
- Stuff the dates with goat cheese, wrap them in bacon, and refrigerate them on their baking sheet.
- Pre-roast and fill the mushroom caps, then cover and refrigerate (add the crumb just before baking).
- Bake the brie bites’ pastry cups and store them airtight.
- Trim and halve the Brussels sprouts, cook the bacon and shallots, and make the cider vinaigrette.
- Trim the green beans and toast the almonds.
- Cut the root vegetables and make the caper gremolata.
- Roast the delicata and beets for the harvest salad, and make its dressing.
- Mix the turkey’s compound butter, then set the table.
Morning of
- Take the turkey out of the fridge 1 hour before roasting and heat the oven to 300°F.
- Butter the turkey and get it in the oven. At 300°F, plan on about 2½–3 hours for a 12-lb bird or 4½–5 hours for a 20-lb bird, before the final blast of heat to crisp the skin.
- Take the gratin and the cheesecake’s raspberry sauce out of the fridge to come toward room temperature.
- Assemble the stuffing in its baking dish and refrigerate until it’s time to bake.
- Toss the carrots with oil and salt on a sheet pan, ready to roast. Do the same with the root vegetables and the Brussels sprouts.
- About an hour before guests arrive, build the charcuterie board, cover it, and keep it cool. Set it out with the fennel dip as people arrive.
- About 1–2 hours before eating, toss the kale with its dressing so it softens. Hold back the pear, pomegranate, goat cheese, and dukkah.
Last hour
- When the turkey comes out, let it rest 30–45 minutes under loose foil. Raise the oven to 400°F.
- While it rests, roast the carrots, root vegetables, and Brussels sprouts (25–35 minutes), bake the stuffing, and reheat both gratins covered with foil, uncovering them for the last 10 minutes. If the oven is crowded, roast the root vegetables in the morning and rewarm them for 10 minutes.
- The warm starters can go in at the same time: bake the dates (20–25 minutes), mushrooms (18–22 minutes), and filled brie bites, and pass them with drinks while you carve. With a second oven or a countertop oven, bake them earlier, as guests arrive.
- Boil and rice the potatoes, beat in the butter and warm cream, and keep them covered over very low heat.
- Blanch and sauté the green beans right before serving, then toss with lemon and almonds.
- Make the gravy on the stovetop from the pan drippings and the reduced stock, then stir in the mushrooms.
- Warm the soup, if serving.
- Carve the turkey. Spoon the pesto and pomegranate over the carrots, and finish the kale salad with pear, pomegranate, goat cheese, and dukkah. Toss and top the harvest salad, and spoon the gremolata over the root vegetables.
- Whip the cream for the pies just before dessert.
Shopping & Sourcing
- Turkey: Order a pasture-raised or heritage turkey from a local farm by late October or early November. Plan on about 1–1½ lb per person for a whole bird, which leaves room for leftovers.
- Dairy: Raw butter, raw cream, and raw-milk cheeses (Gruyère, Parmigiano-Reggiano, goat cheese) from a farmer you know and trust (find one at realmilk.com), or organic, grass-fed, low-temperature pasteurized versions (Kalona SuperNatural).
- Eggs: Organic and pasture-raised, from a local farm (Alexandre Family Farm). The desserts use quite a few, so buy extra.
- Sweeteners and baking: Organic Grade A dark maple syrup, organic unrefined coconut sugar, organic blanched almond flour (keep it in the fridge), and aluminum-free baking soda and powder.
- Bone broth: Homemade from pasture-raised bones, or organic and sold frozen (Bonafide Provisions).
- Produce: Organic, from a farmers’ market or local farm. Pick up apples, pears, pomegranates, cranberries, sweet potatoes, potatoes, rainbow carrots, root vegetables, Brussels sprouts, green beans, delicata squash, fennel, kale, mushrooms, shallots, Medjool dates, and plenty of fresh sage, thyme, and rosemary.
- Starters: Pasture-raised bacon and sausage with no added sugar, raw-milk cheeses for the board (an aged cheddar, a soft brie, a firm sheep’s cheese), and uncured salami or prosciutto.
Season & Circadian Timing
Thanksgiving lands at the very end of the North American harvest, when cranberries, sweet potatoes, apples, pears, and squash are all at their peak, and a pasture-raised turkey has had a full season outdoors. Plan the feast for midday or midafternoon, when digestion is strongest, so you have plenty of daylight left for a walk after the meal and hours to digest before bed. Save dessert for a little later in the afternoon, once everyone has had a chance to settle.
With Love, Light, and Health,
Anna (aka Food Marshall)
Get new recipes and essays
Seasonal recipes and writing on light, circadian health, and living with nature.
Subscribe on Substack